Prefatory Remarks
George William Bagby (1828–1883) was a licensed physician—he studied at University of Pennsylvania—who shunned practice of medicine for his first love, writing. He married Lucy Parke Chamberlayne in 1863, and he had by her 10 children. To make ends meet, as it were, he spent most of his time as an editor.
Bagby was also an unapologetic Southerner. With advent of the American Civil War, Bagby, then editor of Southern Literary Messenger (since 1860), repurposed the magazine for the sake of the Southern cause: He advocated loudly for secessionism and for the Southern way of life, which was slow, relaxed, and agrarian. With surcease of the war, Bagby turned to essays—typically short stories that hearkened back, often mawkishly, to “the days of old.” He never made a living as an essayist, but his essays were witty, often brilliant, and incisive; they captured beautifully what was good and not-so-good in pre-war Virginia and they are empathic.
Born a Northerner who has spent some 10 years in the South (Virginia and Texas), Bagby’s Southern essays concerning the Southern ethos will strike at the hearts of any true Southerner, or even anyone who has spent some time in the South—Virginians especially. I merely note that I have never once heard a Northerner speak warmly and affectionately about the Northern ethos, if there is one (so much for the “Carpetbaggers’” claims about Southern apologism)!
In this essay, Bagby captures brilliantly the habits of many Virginian editors: cigar-smoking, hard-drinking, and fights with other editors (some leading to death).
To give context, I note that newspapers, for instance, at the time were small and highly politicized: Sensationalism drew in readers. Tensions between editors of different publications were large. The most notorious and famous dispute in Lynchburg, Virginia, in Bagby’s day, was between Charles, Joseph, and Robert Button of The Virginian and George and William Hardwicke, assistant editors of The Republic. The story was published even on the west coast. Joe Stinnet, drawing from published accounts, gives the gist of the account, which occurred in June 1860:
The Virginian had charged [Lynchburger] Glass with “dereliction of duty” as postmaster, for leaving town to attend a convention in Baltimore. The next day, the Republican called Charles Button a “coward.” Joseph Button then responded in The Virginian, accusing the Republican’s assistant editor George Hardwicke of cowardice, and describing him as the son of a vagrant. Joseph retracted the “vagrant” comment about Hardwicke’s late father but did not take back his slur on Hardwicke.
Then, on Saturday afternoon, June 23, Charles, Joseph, and Robert Button, with a local minister, were walking home from the office. They encountered George and William Hardwicke, both assistant editors of The Republican, on the corner of 12th and Church streets. Everyone except the minister was armed. Charles told the minister to drop back, and the shooting began, with the Hardwickes firing first, according to later testimony. Joseph Button was killed, and Robert Button was wounded.
A witness said that he had tried to intercede in the days before the gunfight, but when the Buttons did not fully apologize, one Hardwicke said something along the lines of, “Well, let’s shoot them.”
Button’s paper covered the trial with a full-page report in November 1860. George Hardwicke was found not guilty, despite witnesses who testified that Hardwicke and his brothers had basically ambushed the Buttons.
After decrying the verdict, blaming it on politics, and wondering if everyone would need to go around armed (which apparently they did anyway) Button managed to maintain his editorial dignity— “after as calm a review of this whole affair as we are capable of”—and pledged to never mention [sic] the shooting again in the paper, a promise he apparently kept.

The Virginia Editor by George William Bagby
The Virginia Editor is a young, unmarried, intemperate, pugnacious, gambling gentleman. Between drink and dueling-pistols he is generally escorted to a premature grave. If he so far withstands the ravages of brandy and gunpowder as to reach the
period of gray hairs and cautiousness, he is deposed to make room for a youth who hates his life with an utter hatred, and who can”t keep drunk more than a week at a time.
Deposed, he becomes a literary ostrich, and may be seen, with swollen red nose and diminished, calfless shanks, migrating from court-house to court-house, laying a newspaper egg, which he leaves to be hatched into life and permanence by the pecuniary warmth of the party to whom he sells out at a small advance. Or he gets the lofty position of clerk in Washington. Should he, by rare good luck and the miraculous interposition of Providence, have saved any money, he buys a property in the country, retires to it, debauches himself with miscellaneous literature, lounges much and does a great deal of nothing at all. Should he get married, he sinks into an obscure and decent citizen, and looks back upon his early career as a horrid dream.
Previous to his death, the Virginia editor makes the most of the short time allotted to him on earth by living at a suicidal velocity. To test the strength of his constitution, by subjecting it to the influence of the most destructive habits and agencies, appears to be his sole pleasure and aim. He is determined not to live longer than he can possibly help. A quiet death at a ripe old age he regards as a disgrace.
His first waking moments in the morning are saturated with a number of powerful cocktails, to cure a headache, “brought over,” as an accountant would say, from the previous midnight. Cocktailed past the point of nervousness and remorse, he dresses himself and wends his way to a barber shop to get shaved, if he shaves at all. Not unfrequently he has himself shaved in bed. Breakfast succeeds, and then, with a cigar in his mouth, he enters his sanctum and goes to work, which work consists in hunting for insults in his exchanges, and in laying the foundation, by means of a scathing article, of a future duel. While employed upon his leading article he suffers no interruption, except from the gentleman who brings a note from another gentleman, whom he (the editor) grossly insulted at an oyster supper the night before. Having no earthly recollection of any such occurrence, the editor feels no hesitation (unless he happens to be unusually bilious, or has no “affair” upon his hands), in saying that he “fully and frankly withdraws any and every expression reflecting upon the character of the gentleman, as a gentleman and a man of honor.”
His editorial labors vary from five minutes to two hours and a half in duration. If he feels very badly he won’t write at all, but goes armed with a stick to a neighboring law office, and threatens the occupant with a caning unless he has a spicy article in the compositor’s hands by such an hour. The unhappy barrister complies, and spices the editor into a scrape, for which the editor is unaffectedly thankful, swearing he would die without excitement.
Before leaving his sanctum he answers a couple of letters which arrived by the last mail. He engages to meet “the gallant Democracy of ******** district,” and to address them on “August court-day.” He assures a “constant reader” that “the glorious cause is prospering, the skies brightening;” and suggests, as the best means of putting the issue of the canvass—“the most momentous canvass that ever occurred in the history of the Republic”—beyond a doubt, that the “constant reader” shall send in ten new subscribers to the Keepa P’dchinin. He then huddles a shirt, a case of dueling pistols, and a bottle of “Otard” into a small trunk, and goes to the telegraph office to notify a brother editor that he will be in Washington to-morrow night, waiting for him at the National Hotel. His mind being thus relieved of business, he has nothing to do but to wander off to his hotel, to look at the register and see if anybody has come. He meets there with another editor—a red-headed provincial fresh from the mountains, and already heavily laden with “rifle whisky”—with whom he proceeds, without delay, to drink juleps and talk politics until dinner-time.
After dinner he borrows twice as much money as will take him to Washington and back, reserving the surplus to bet that night at the faro-bank.
In his personal appearance, the Virginia editor vibrates between positive gentility and absolute shabbiness, and this irrespective of his condition as to “funds.” At times he is smooth and clean of face, immaculate in shirt, perfect of boot and hat; at others he is great in beard and dirt, resembling an uncleansed pressman, or a pirate who has cruised for years upon an ocean of ink. He rarely buys clothes until he is in immediate need of them; and, inasmuch as he lives all over the State, is quite as apt to have on somebody else’s clothes as his own. He despises a fashionable, dandified man as he does a man who drinks weak drinks. He vindicates his Democracy, even in his liquor; believes in good old brandy or whisky, calls them “strict construction drinks,” while malt liquors he stigmatizes as “compromise drinks,” and will have nothing to do with them, except to “taper off” on.
There is nothing in his form or features to distinguish him from other men. A physiognomist might, perhaps, detect in his face a bloody good-nature—an amiability easily kindled into anger—as if the fierce animal instincts of the man were but imperfectly subdued by the pressure of social refinements.
His negligence in dress is not greater than his carelessness with regard to another comfort which the majority of mankind deem essential to happiness. He will live upon the best of food, will drink the best liquors, and smoke the finest cigars, but is utterly indifferent as to where or how he sleeps, provided he has a bed-fellow; for he is greatly social, and cannot bear ever to be alone. Every respectable young man living in the same city is secure against an invasion of the editor at the most inopportune hours of the night. How many sweet dreams have been rudely broken by his assaults upon the front door, or his noisy escalade of the back-window, it would be impossible to tell.
He has a room of his own, originally furnished with some taste and care, but has a mortal antipathy to sleeping in it. Nor is this aversion to be wondered at. Through a puddle of newspapers, congressional speeches, tobacco juice, cigar stumps, broken spit-boxes, and pipesterns, he wades to a bed whose sheets bade adieu to the washerwoman at a period too remote to be recalled, and whose counterpane secretes its primitive tints under a sweet and greasy scum of spermaceti and spilled brandy toddies.
A candle-stand is drawn conveniently near the yellow pillow, and on it lie, disorderly, a candle burned to the socket, a fragmentary volume of Byron, a plug of tobacco, a cork (fellow to others on the floor), an inkstand without any ink in it, and a foolscap scrap of unfinished editorial. Upon the window-sill, near the foot of the bed, stands marshaled a platoon of 8 various-sized bottles, from the grenadier champagne to the squatty porter and the slab-sided tickler. In the little wardrobe are no clothes, except a skeleton waistcoat gibbeted upon a broken hook, but a number of empty cigar-boxes, a bowie-knife and a revolver. In the waistcoat pocket may be found a free railroad ticket, which ticket he never presents, for the conductors are much better acquainted with him than with the schedule. The odor of this apartment is not inviting. The door is always open, night and day, and it is the common dormitory of all belated roysterers. Any one may sleep here who chooses.
Notwithstanding his habits, the editor obtains a popularity wholly disproportioned, one would say, to his merits. That he should achieve notoriety is no matter for surprise, when every number of every paper issued in the State contains the name of Derringer Thundergust, or William Jeems Rawhead, as principal, second, or adjustant of some personal difficulty; but notoriety is one thing and popularity another and very different thing.
Habits which would outlaw any other man enable him to ride rough-shod over the inviolable law of custom. Conduct which would damn a man in business endears him to men in whose creed “strict business habits” rank next to, if they do not take precedence of, godliness. Grave men—the slaves of routine and propriety—appear to take the same delight in witnessing his unbridled eccentricities that inspired the poet Job when contemplating the gambols of the wild ass. There is an airy bravado in his outrages, a gay candor and naturalness in his excesses, which extract all their sting. As soon quarrel with the habits of a strange bird as with those of a being who is not a man, but an editor, and to whom no gauge of human morals is in any particular applicable.
His abhorrence of the vice of solitary drinking has a good deal to do with this popularity. Scarcely a respectable citizen can be found in the commonwealth with whom he has not, at some time or other, hobnobbed in a friendly manner. Rather than drink alone he will drink with a negro, provided the negro is at all genteel, and has a gentleman for his master.
His Ethiopian popularity is immense. It could hardly be otherwise when, from the White Sulphur Springs to the city of Norfolk, he has repeatedly and extravagantly feed everything answering to the name of “waiter.”
The Virginia editor is not a pious, nor, strictly speaking, a gallant man. Women, children, and preachers he classes under the common head of “non-combatants,” and views them pretty much in the light in which he regards flies—as species of not very harmful, somewhat abundant insects, perhaps useful, but whose uses are not yet well understood. Still, he makes it a point of honor to place implicit faith in the truth of the Christian religion and the virtue of women; and while he regards the softer sex as, at best, beautiful toys, they are glass toys, and he treads respectfully and gingerly among the frail vessels. He clings with sectarian tenacity to the belief in future rewards and punishments; he is too brave and resentful a man to think otherwise. A disbelief in hell he denounces as the “poltroonery of infidelity,” nor can any casuistry convince him that a man is not as responsible for his faith as he is for his actions.
He loves to talk, and his great theme, after politics, is himself. In himself he has the most unbounded confidence—a confidence which, in the most trying emergencies, scarcely ever deserts him. Through difficulties that would appall and crush ordinary men, he moves with the smiling abandon of a knight-errant pricking onward to meet a dragon, gorgon, or chimera dire. Only in moments of extreme nervous depression will he admit himself not competent to the discharge of the most arduous and varied duties of life, and especially of those duties for which he is evidently unfitted. He looks upon himself as pre-eminently a man of business—a practical man. Rothschild was not his equal in financiering ability; Napoleon nor Hampden could have wearied him in work; Halifax was not his superior in political sagacity. Name any man who has succeeded or failed in any undertaking, he will instantly unfold to you the secret of his success, or the oversight which led to his downfall.
“But for cards and liquor,” himself would have excelled any man of his acquaintance; as it is, see how well he gets along in the world. In truth, his mind is strictly of the “nil admirari” [nothing to be admired] order; he worships no man; and his regard for himself is only a reluctant indulgence accorded not to what lie is, but to what he ought to be, and would be, but for cards and liquor.”
For this remarkable self-confidence he is indebted partly to a nature eminently high-spirited, and partly to his position. Like the driver of a locomotive, he wields a power infinitely greater than his own. He handles the lever that unlooses the throttle-valve of the mightiest engine on earth, and it is but natural that he should confound derived with individual power. Disconnect him from his engine, let him conduct a business, other than his own, upon the same loose principles, he would soon discover his error. But then he would lose one of his most delightful traits.
The Virginia editor is not a profoundly learned man; he is not even a smatterer, in the sense, at least, in which that equivocal compliment was paid to Milton. His specialty is politics; and his tastes not less than his occupation conspire to prevent his acquiring any other knowledge. Of Latin he remembers a few terms, such as “ex post facto” and “ex parte” which he picked up while drifting, for a few weeks, through a law office. Of Greek he retains nearly the whole alphabet, being only a little uncertain as to the relative shapes of Zeta and Xi, and confusing Phi with Psi. His stock of poetry consists of a few scraps of Hudibras, Byron, and Peter Pindar; he has, besides, a professional pride and tenderness for the quatrain commencing: “Truth, crushed to earth, will rise again I.” It would be impossible to restrain him from quoting this occasionally, and, if it were possible, it would be cruel.
His historical information does not extend quite to the times of the Achaian League and the Amphictyonic Council, but dates rather from the Resolutions of “98. With the wordings of the American government, from its inception down to the present time; with the character, and, to an extent, with the writings of the great men who took prominent part in its formation; with the policy of the party leaders; with the politicians, great and small, of his own times, and with their tactics, he is intimately familiar. In fact, his attainments may be summed up in the word “politics”; for while he does not underrate those who understand and take an interest in Belles Lettres and the Arts and Sciences, he frankly confesses that he knows and cares nothing about them himself. So fitted is he for partisan journalism, and so wedded to it, that it is to be hoped the divine economy has set apart some waste democratic star, some uncleared portion of the celestial public domain, some half-settled nebulous Kansas as a newspaper heaven for him and his fellows. Elsewhere no conceivable use could be found for them.
His style in writing varies from the plainest Anglo-Saxon to the most gorgeous highfalutin. In general, however, he makes use of ordinary English, and cares little or nothing about nicety and finish. He is better at repartee than at argument, but prefers hard talk to the most polished wit. His humor is peculiar, and considerably wider than it is subtle.
It has been said by some that the Virginia editor is chosen rather for the stoutness of his heart than for the brilliancy of his intellect, and, to be honest, there is some truth in the allegation. A newspaper, to be successful in the Old Dominion, must not be defective in what they call chivalry; and a long-established paper, having the prestige of high-toned valor, would hardly employ a ready-writing craven in preference to a brave gentleman less facile with the pen. But the requirements of the public in this regard, and the usages of the papers, have been a thought exaggerated.
It is not true, for example, that the man-of-all-work, the “Caesar” of the office, who is employed to sweep out the old papers and trash in the morning, receives an additional compensation for sweeping in the dead editors lying about the door, who have been killed at various places during the night and brought there, as to a Morgue, for recognition and distribution. Neither is it true that a paper, in order to keep up its circulation, must have at least one editor killed a day, and that papers having secured a good editor, one whom they are unwilling to lose, are in the habit of imposing upon the public by buying up worthless wretches to assassinate in place of him. Equally unfounded is the report that papers impoverished and doing a small business are forced to practice the contemptible fraud of substituting wooden dummies, manikins, or lay figures in place of bona fide corpses. These reports have reference, doubtless, to States farther South than Virginia.
A propensity for gaming is a part of the editor’s constitution—an hereditary taint, for which he is no more responsible than for the age of his grandfather, and which he could as easily get rid of as remove the shape of his legs. The affliction being eminently genteel, he not only bears up under it with manly fortitude, but cherishes it with much regard. He is not much of a hand at “short cards.” His delight is to be seated over against a grim, imperturbable faro-dealer—to have bets of “red checks” all over the table—half a dozen “piddlers” of “white chips” to be leaning over his shoulder and admiring his nerve — a negro to be patiently awaiting the end of the deal to hand him a brandy toddy on a silver waiter—for the game to be stoutly contested, and himself to “come out right smartly winner.” He has no great faith in “cases,” but believes in betting on three cards at a time, and has a special hankering for “the pot.”
After all, and in spite of his many faults, the Virginia Editor is a gentleman. He comes of a good stock, and, however wild he may be, never disgraces it by a low or mean action. His vices are not those of a groveling spirit. If his temper is hot, it is not implacable; if his resentment is quick, it never seeks an underhanded revenge. If he prefers a clean bullet-hole to a fisticuffish bruising or mangling with a bludgeon, that is his own concern. If he is a sturdy partisan, he is above the venality and the trimming which disgraces the journalism of States nearer the pole than his own. If he drinks too much, it is because the liquor he uses is of the best quality. If he gambles, it is because he can”t help it. If he lives something beyond his income, he is doing no more than all enlightened nations and the majority of great men have done and continue to do. His tastes are lavish. An imperial gallon cannot be contained in a quart pot. And what political fabric was ever reared or maintained in its integrity without the aid of an occasional loan? If he is not a very good citizen, it is because he wants to be a better editor.
Finally, half an ounce of lead is “honorably and satisfactorily adjusted “in his heart or brain, and the Virginia Editor dies, to the great joy of himself and to the intense grief of his party,—the faro-dealers, the bar-keepers, and of every body who is entitled to an unexpected fifty cents simply because he is a negro and can run an errand. The no longer belligerent remains are attended to the tomb by an immense concourse of citizens of all parties, and the epitaph, stale but true, is, that “the community could have better spared a better man.”
The views expressed at AbbevilleInstitute.org are not necessarily those of the Abbeville Institute.





